Moderator: Moderators


raijanni wrote: soderling is playing so well,he will beat anybody, nadal will only win if soderling loses or plays below par.



PKBasu wrote:Actually, I would agree that the blast of new faces in the latter stages of a Slam -- Soderling (ok he's new only relative to 2008), Berdych, Stosur (a la Soderling) beating Henin, etc. -- is good for tennis. Now for someone to beat Nadal on clay...

PKBasu wrote:Then it was 40-30, and Soderling called a ball from Federer out, the line judge agreed but the umpire checked the spot and called it in -- and asked them to replay the point! (Actually the line judge must have called it out, and Soderling left it -- though he seemed to have also tried to judge it out and left the ball). On the replayed serve, Soderling served an ace to end the set. I think it should have been called deuce when the previous shot was called in by the umpire.
No way any chair umpire could give the point to Federer. Line judge clearly called it out and everybody heard that and Soderling had a play on that ball. The point is whether the player had a play on that ball (this is not the case in a clear winner) under normal circumstances, now since the line judge called it out so play was stopped and the point was over, The duty of the chair umpire now is to check whether he made the right call. If not then the point will be replayed but no way Soderling could be penalized for that bcoz play was interrupted by the line judge and he had to stop.I mean this is the rule. And there is no question of influencing the line judge. They make their own decisions. Actually the ball was going out but at the last moment it dipped in due to some spin on that. Soderling also probably thought the ball was going out and so he did not make any serious attempt of play but since the line judge aslo called it out so that's it, the point was over and officially he had a play on that ball. This is not the case of ' stop play and challenge the line call'. Of course you can say that Soderling was lucky but you cant blame the chair umpire. He did the right thing.








Return to General Tennis Discussion
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest